Manslaughter Park by Tirzah Price Review

Hello Readers,
Manslaughter Park is the third instalment in the Jane Austen Murder Mystery series that I've picked up and after falling in love with Pride and Premeditation and Sense & Second-Degree Murder, I couldn’t resist diving into this one too.

 
Out of all three of Tirzah Price’s Austen-inspired murder mystery retellings, Manslaughter Park was the one I approached with a mix of excitement and trepidation. I’ve always had a love-hate relationship with Mansfield Park, so I was curious to see how Price would reimagine Fanny Price’s story. The dedication, which was to “everyone who thought Fanny Price deserved better,” immediately won me over—it felt like a perfect nod to the heart of this retelling.
 
And I have to say, I loved it. In Manslaughter Park, Fanny Price is on a mission to uncover the truth behind her uncle’s murder, and her journey is full of twists and revelations. Along the way, she’s joined by her friends and some unexpected allies, each adding layers to her investigation and to her own growth. This YA queer retelling gave me exactly what I didn’t know I was craving a story that honours the essence of Austen’s characters while making them feel fresh and relevant for today’s readers.
 
In Manslaughter Park, Tirzah Price cleverly reimagines Austen’s original dynamics, shifting the spotlight away from the traditional male leads and elevating Mary Crawford as Fanny’s unexpected—and utterly fitting—love interest. It’s a bold move that feels just right for this version of Fanny, and one that will thrill readers who’ve long wished for a different romantic outcome in Mansfield Park.
 
The romance is tender and charming, filled with the hesitations and heart-racing moments of first love. But, as with the previous books in the series, it’s the mystery that propels the plot. Fanny’s early stumbles into amateur sleuthing add charm and humour, and she’s supported by the ever-enchanting duo of Lizzie and Darcy as the trio follows clues, builds theories, and races toward a satisfying, twisty conclusion.
 
I adore how Price takes the beloved characters from Mansfield Park and breathes new life into them, recontextualizing their relationships and motivations within the framework of a thrilling murder mystery. She strikes the perfect balance between Austen’s sharp social commentary and witty character development, while adding the irresistible intrigue of a cozy mystery. Fanny gets the story she always deserved one where she isn’t just a passive observer, but an active, strong heroine uncovering truths, both about the case and herself.
 
What’s most impressive is how Price blends all the best elements of Austen’s work: the careful character development, the social critique, and the compelling female lead. At the same time, she delivers a gripping mystery that keeps the pages turning. Manslaughter Park is more than just a retelling; it’s a coming-of-age story, a commentary on society, and a murder mystery wrapped into one fantastic package.
 
Overall, this series has been such a joy to read, and Manslaughter Park is no exception. It’s fun, smart, and full of surprises—a perfect blend of Austen’s timeless appeal and the engaging twists of a modern mystery.

Comments